First published: December 2021.

On Wednesday, the Independent Monitoring Authority for the Citizens’ Rights Agreements (IMA) launched a lawsuit against the Home Office for breaching the terms of the Withdrawal Agreements for people who have been granted pre-settled status.

The IMA’s Statement of Facts and Grounds. | Independent Monitoring Authority for the Citizens’ Rights Agreements (IMA)

Dr Kathryn Chamberlain, Chief Executive of the IMA said: “In taking legal action now we hope to provide clarity for those citizens with Pre-Settled Status of which there are 2.485 million as of 30 November 2021.”

Indeed, people will lose their rights to live in the UK if they don’t convert their pre-settled status to settled status within 5 years of being granted status. We have warned the Home Office that it was incompatible with the terms of the Withdrawal Agreement and we wrote to the IMA in February 2021 (page 29):

Automatic loss of pre-settled status
For someone with pre-settled status who continues to live in the UK, doesn’t break their continuity of residence or any other eligibility criterion, but simply forgets to apply for settled status before their pre-settled status expires, the consequences are hard to overstate.

They lose their lawful basis to be in the UK, they face the full policies of the hostile environment namely potential loss of job, rental accommodation, driving licence, access to healthcare. All for forgetting an administrative procedure.

the3million consider that this loss of status is not compliant with the Withdrawal Agreement. Whereas e.g. levying financial penalties for not applying in time would be allowed, Article 20 of the Withdrawal Agreement does not cover loss of status for lack of an administrative action.

The risks to nearly 2.5 million EU citizens and family members with pre-settled status cannot be understated and we ask the UK Government to do the right thing to avoid another Windrush and put the required safeguards in place to make sure no one faces losing their livelihoods simply because they forgot to fill in a form.

Report your problems

We pride ourselves on giving a voice to EU citizens in the UK. Your stories and your problems are our stories and our problems.

If you, or someone you know, are struggling to apply or prove their status or can’t access rights under the EU Settlement Scheme, please tell us using our online form: (available in multiple European languages)

By reporting them to us, you make sure your problem is analysed and raised with the authorities, including our reports to the IMA.

PMP Magazine

▪ Follow our Twitter account: @the3million
▪ Like our Facebook page:
▪ Join the conversation with over 45,000 fellow EU citizens in the Facebook Forum for EU citizens:
▪ Sign up to receive the3million newsletter in your inbox at:


the3million, the largest group of EU citizens in the UK.
Nicolas Hatton, CEO of the3million.


Going Further:

Creative Commons License

Written by:

[Read our Comments Guidelines]